S E R V E R   S I D E
View current page
...more recent posts

Current design mantra: everything happens in the browser, and information flows both ways.
- jim 8-02-2001 2:43 pm [link] [add a comment]

I always cringe when someone uses the "free speach doesn't give you the right to shout fire in a crowded theatre" argument. Someone used this today on Metafilter, and as I clicked through to the comments I was hoping someone would have already set the record straight. Score one for the bloggers:

That quote was from an opinion (Schenck v. U.S.) by Jusice Oliver Wendell Holmes. (Holmes later backpedaled from this idea, creating the "marketplace of ideas" concept in his equally-famous dissent in Abrams v. U.S.)

The "fire in a crowded theater" test, also known as the "clear and present danger" test, was used to justify the conviction, under the Espionage Act, of a socialist protester for distributing leaflets protesting the draft for Americans in the first World War. The leaflet allegedly endangered the war effort.

I think it's pretty clear today that the ideas contained in that leaflet fall squarely within the bounds of First Amendment protection. But even though Holmes later changed his mind, hindsight shows that the government was clearly wrong, the "fire" quote is used to justify all sorts of restrictions on speech today.

posted by mikewas at 8:34 AM PST on August 1

- jim 8-01-2001 6:51 pm [link] [2 refs] [1 comment]

I had an interesting business meeting last night. I don't think I had realized before that I've been waiting to meet a certain kind of person. My skill set is so lopsided. I guess this is true of most people. Still, it's hard to see until you meet someone who seems to be good at what you are not. And when such a meeting produces genuine enthusiasm it's a really great feeling. Go team.

More to hopefully follow.
- jim 8-01-2001 4:41 pm [link] [add a comment]

older posts...